If you’re going to be a hater, make sure you’ve done your homework.

I can imagine that, for a teacher, a GCSE religious studies lesson on racism may be one of the most challenging classes to teach, especially in a school like mine; overrun with teenage girls desperate to voice their opinions in an attempt to seem more intelligent than their classmates.

The other week, I was sitting in class, learning about prejudice, already pissed off having had to discuss why ‘reverse racism’ is simply just ‘racism.’ Doodling Radiohead lyrics over my folder and pondering why on earth I had chosen to study RS, I couldn’t help but tune into a conversation between two of my classmates. One girl, for the sake of privacy let’s call her Jennifer, was explaining to a friend why Israel obviously belongs to the Arabs, not the Jews. Fair enough, if she has evidence to support this. But what Jennifer said next surely would’ve angered anybody, let alone a girl like me whose family has been directly affected by anti-Semitism. “The Jews could’ve stayed in Germany after the war, instead of going to Israel. What Hitler did sucked, but it didn’t just effect the Jews.”

The idea of the Jews staying in Germany after the war is, for blatantly obvious reasons, utter bullshit.

How could the Jews possibly stay in Germany? The country was in ruins, physically and economically. Children had been separated from their parents and the concept of ‘home’ had been completely eviscerated. How can you immediately rebuild a community that has been destroyed to such an extent? In 1933, when Hitler became chancellor, there was circa 500,000 Jews living in Germany. By 1950, there was only 37,000. Why stay in a country in which you have experienced the most severe trauma?

What Jennifer has done here is made the very link between anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism which racists everywhere deny they are doing. It is perfectly possible to be against the Israeli government and their brutal domestic policy, and simultaneously not be an anti-Semite. But as soon as you relate the Holocaust to the Arab-Israeli conflict in the way that has been done here, you are both insensitive and ignorant.

Just to clarify, I agree completely with the fact that the Holocaust is not personal to Jews alone, as other minorities were also persecuted. But Jennifer is implying that the Jews are, in a sense, making it out to be worse than it was. 6 million Jews were murdered in the Holocaust. We are allowed to be upset. We must talk about the Holocaust today, because if we do not do so, then eventually, it will just become a terrible story that you hear from your grandparents, but never believe is true.

Click here to read a piece I wrote on the importance of remembering the Holocaust, which was published in the Jewish News in 2014.

For a moment, I would like to de-personalise this story- to ensure its objectivity, I have reflected on what really bothered me about what I heard.

Once all reference to my cultural roots had been edited out, and it had been reconstructed as a skeletal story, I had the following realisation. I worked out that what bothered me the most was not the direction of the hate, but the absence of honesty or intellectual rigour in its construct.

If you want to be a revisionist, be a revisionist. If you want to hate Israel, hate Israel. If you want to hate Trump, hate Trump, and ditto Hilary. But don’t conflate your hatreds into one unfathomable mass, or we won’t be able to see you coming.

I am sick to death of self-righteous, self-proclaimed ‘liberal’ girls, who think that, because they are at an international school, they cannot possible be racist. I am sick to death of people who think they can assume their opinion prevails over everybody else’s, without even attempting to see both sides of the argument, or give accurate evidence. You cannot truly be a liberal, let alone an intellectual, if you do not have reasonable backing and foundations behind your beliefs. Get over it.

(The publication of this article has catalysed debate amongst the community that I live in, including some healthy closure on the issue between the key players. I would like to clarify that whilst I stand by every point I have made, my opening annecdote was merely a tool to get across a wider idea. People don’t always consider the wider significance and possible interpretations of their words, and it is important for me to emphasise that things like this should not define someone as a person.)

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “If you’re going to be a hater, make sure you’ve done your homework.

  1. Reblogged this on From guestwriters and commented:
    One great problem by hate against others is the non-knowledge of those others. The not knowing enough of history is the second part which makes that hate crimes and socio-political situations can re-occur.

    A video published this weekend by a politician from Gent showed clearly how people from different communities took over words they heard adults shouting at each other. As such we do hear young Moroccans calling to have all “the Makakken (sobriquet for Moroccans) out”, dark skinned girls shouting to get all niggers or Negroes where they belong, etc.. It is quite confronting to see how those young, so called innocent toddlers and teens,call their own group of people names, not really understanding the content of such calling and the hate they would or could create with it.

    The pictures clearly show how an attitude of hate or love is created by the ones responsible for the education (parents, teachers, surrounding society) of the youngsters and the next generation.

    Like

  2. Those that ‘Don’t know what they don’t know’ and lack self-awareness are ignorant by any other name- but what Marcus and Lola have done have beautifully illustrated specific examples of the same ignorance in a seemingly different contexts.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Congratulation with your first and nice article on WordPress.

    You write about the girl wanting the Jews to stay in Germany, but does she knows there where not many Jews alive any more in Germany at the end of World War II? And why should there have been German surviving Jews having to go back to a country where they had experienced a lot of hate and which had cause them so much torture?

    Not only for Jews the country was in ruins, physically and economically. Germans also had to rebuild their life and their country. You know they even ended up more restored than many of the countries the Germans had invaded? For sure we could see how much quicker Germany had constructed beautiful cities again, whilst we in our countries where still battling with the events of destruction.

    The most severe trauma lots of Jews did not encounter in their home country, but at the places where they were transported to.

    You are totally right. Much too many people consider those who are against what is going on in Israel, to be anti-semitic, but they can be themselves real Jews as well as real lovers of Jews.

    One of the great problems of the disturbance in relationships with Jews is that

    “as soon as you relate the Holocaust to the Arab-Israeli conflict in the way that has been done here, you are both insensitive and ignorant.”

    Zionism has not so much to do with the fundamentalist Jews taking of land from the Palestinians, who are also human beings created in the image of God, who reside in the land God has provided for them.
    All people should know that Jerusalem is going to be the capital of the Holy Land and of the Kingdom of God, but that does not give the sole right for Jews to be the only ones to live there or to worship there.

    People also should see the clear difference between the Jewish race with lots of civic and non religious Jews, who often are the ones who want to step on their stripes to have more power and more territory. It are mainly those non-religious Jews who also voted for things which are not only an abomination in the eyes of God but which are also against human rights. Let us therefore not be mistaken and always see the difference between the not in God believing Jews, the fundamentalist Jews, the materialist Zionists, the Zionists hoping to find God’s promised Land, and the real lovers of God and sincere religious Jews.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s